[ClamsTheCat]

I would not say I have load with either, but in my experimentation with both I believe that BTV is clearly the better and more mature product. It has loads of features and they update it fairly often. The only thing I am chomping at the bit for is HDTV capture from a cable box, but that is not really their fault. Until someone makes the hardware with composite capture capability, we will be stuck with non-HD digital cable.

You should download the BTV demo and check it out for yourself. I used demos of each and clearly saw that BTV was better. It has a really neat interface.